Fiscal-Cadastral Value in Spanish resales

Understanding “Complementaria Letters” from the Spanish Tax Office: When You Buy a Bargain Property

In recent years, it has become increasingly common for property buyers in Spain, especially those who have acquired properties at seemingly “bargain” prices, to receive unexpected letters from the regional tax office. These letters, known as “complementarias” which is a request for additional tax payments based on the tax office’s reassessment of the property’s value. If you’ve bought a property in Spain at what you believed was a good deal, understanding the implications of these complementaria letters is crucial to avoid unexpected financial obligations.

 What are “Complementaria Letters”?

A “complementaria” is a formal communication from the Spanish regional tax office informing you that the value of the property you purchased is being re-evaluated. Essentially, the tax office claims that the price you declared for the property (the “Real-Commercial Value”) is lower than what they consider the “Fiscal Value” or the true market value. As a result, they demand additional taxes based on this higher Fiscal Value.

 Why Do These Letters Exist?

Under Spanish law, the tax office has the authority to override the declared values of property transactions if they believe the price was understated. This mechanism is in place to ensure that taxes are paid based on the fair market value of the property, rather than potentially manipulated or undervalued figures that might reduce tax obligations.

A Practical Example: The “Complementaria” in Action

Let’s break down the situation with a practical example:

– You purchase a resale property in the Valencian Region for €345,000.
– Real-Commercial Value: The purchase price you paid and declared is €345,000.
– Transfer Tax (ITP): In the Valencian Region, the Transfer Tax rate is 10%, so you initially pay €34,500 in taxes based on the declared purchase price.

However, the Spanish tax administration has the right to inspect this transaction for up to 4-5 years after the purchase. During this period, the tax office may re-evaluate the property’s value and decide that, based on their criteria, the property should have been valued at €400,000 instead of €345,000. This re-assessed value is what we refer to as the **Fiscal Value**.

The Consequences of a Fiscal Value Adjustment

If the tax office determines that the Fiscal Value of your property is €400,000, they will issue a complementaria letter demanding additional taxes. Here’s how they calculate it:

– Original Tax Paid: 10% of €345,000 (Real-Commercial Value) = €34,500
– Re-assessed Tax Due: 10% of €400,000 (Fiscal Value) = €40,000
– Difference: €40,000 – €34,500 = €5,500

You would be required to pay this additional €5,500 as the tax owed on the difference between the declared value and the re-assessed Fiscal Value.

How to Detect the Fiscal Value of a Property

One of the key concerns for buyers is how to anticipate or detect what the tax office might consider the Fiscal Value of a property. Fortunately, there are methods to estimate this value:

Official Catastro Website

The Fiscal Value of a property can be checked on the official Catastro website in Spain. However, access to this information requires a digital certificate, which is a form of electronic identification used for various official purposes in Spain. Typically, your lawyer can obtain this information during the property purchase process.

Property Valuation by a Specialist

Even if you obtain the Fiscal Value from the Catastro, there is still a risk that the tax office may contest the declared price within the 4-5 year window. To safeguard against this, it is advisable to commission a formal “property valuation” by a qualified specialist, such as an architect, at the time of purchase. This valuation provides a professional assessment of the property’s market value, which can serve as evidence if the tax office challenges the declared price.

 Why Is the Fiscal Value Important?

Understanding the Fiscal Value is important for several reasons:

– Tax Liability

Knowing the Fiscal Value helps you anticipate potential tax liabilities that could arise from a complementaria letter. If the Fiscal Value is significantly higher than the price you paid, you may want to prepare for the possibility of additional taxes.

– Transaction Planning

If you’re aware that the Fiscal Value is higher than your purchase price, you can plan your finances accordingly or reconsider the timing or structure of the transaction to minimize potential tax exposure.

– Legal Protection

A professional valuation report from an architect can provide a strong defense if the tax office disputes the declared value. This report can help you argue that the price you paid reflects the true market value of the property.

What to Do If You Receive a Complementaria Letter

Receiving a complementaria letter can be stressful, but there are steps you can take to manage the situation:

1. Consult Your Lawyer

Immediately consult with your lawyer, who can help you understand the letter and the additional tax being demanded. Your lawyer will also review the details of the transaction and the Fiscal Value determined by the tax office.

2. Review the Property Valuation

If you had a professional valuation done at the time of purchase, this document will be crucial in supporting your case. Your lawyer can present this valuation as evidence that the declared price was accurate.

3. Appeal the Decision

If you believe that the re-assessed Fiscal Value is unfair or inaccurate, you have the right to appeal the tax office’s decision. Your lawyer can guide you through the appeals process, which may involve submitting additional evidence or negotiating with the tax authorities.

4. Paying the Additional Tax

If an appeal is not possible or unsuccessful, you may need to pay the additional tax. Ensure that you do so within the deadlines specified in the complementaria letter to avoid further penalties or interest.

The Legal Context: Why Spain Uses Complementaria Letters

Spain’s use of complementaria letters is part of a broader effort to ensure that property transactions are taxed fairly and accurately. Given that property values can be subjective and that buyers and sellers might have incentives to declare lower prices to reduce tax burdens, the Spanish tax authorities have a vested interest in verifying these values. The complementaria process serves as a check on under-reporting and helps maintain the integrity of the property tax system.

 Practical Tips for Property Buyers in Spain

To avoid the stress and financial burden of receiving a complementaria letter, consider the following tips:

– Always Obtain a Professional Valuation

This should be standard practice when purchasing property, especially if you’re buying at a price that seems lower than the market average.

– Consult with a Lawyer Early

Engage a lawyer early in the purchasing process to ensure that all aspects of the transaction are handled correctly and to minimize the risk of future disputes with the tax authorities.

– Be Prepared for Additional Costs

Even if you believe the purchase price reflects the property’s true value, be financially prepared for the possibility of a complementaria and additional tax liabilities.

– Monitor the 4-5 Year Period

Keep in mind that the tax office can review your transaction for up to 4-5 years. Keep records and stay informed about your property’s valuation during this period.

Conclusion

Buying a property at a bargain price in Spain can come with hidden risks, particularly in the form of complementaria letters from the tax office. These letters demand additional taxes based on a re-assessment of the property’s value, which can significantly impact your financial planning. By understanding the concept of Real-Commercial Value versus Fiscal Value, seeking professional valuations, and consulting with legal experts, you can better navigate the complexities of property taxation in Spain and protect yourself from unexpected tax liabilities.

TLACORP SLP